As a photographer I’m always interested in what other photographers are up to when it comes to their creative work, interests, subject matter and so on. Over the past couple of years though I’ve really noticed a trend that has caught my eye. What I’m seeing is that much of the work being exhibited and sold by photographers looks the same to me – the overall work seems less inspired and imaginative.
It’s almost like these photographers are looking at each others works and copying a technique or image that’s in demand. Possibly this can be blamed on the internet where the same images and latest trends are repeated over and over. I don’t know what the reason is for the uninspired work, but it’s something I’ve noticed and is becoming more apparent with each art festival or show that I attend.
Common Rules, Common Teachings
Personally I think there’s a couple of reasons why a photographer would copy someone else’s imagery. Probably the first and foremost reason is that they feel they can create a better photograph technically or artistically. Another reason might be that the photographer thinks that there’s high demand for that same image and they basically want to cater to that demand.
The real reason why I think everyone’s work looks so much the same to me has more to do with the fact that there are just too many photographers that are following the exact same photography composition rules and advice. To be honest, I think there are just way too many rules about photography composition techniques. In fact, I would go so far to say that the medium of photography is THE most rule-ladened visual art medium today.
What’s I also think is happening is that there are just too many instructors out there teaching the exact same photography composition rules. The result is that photography has become kind of an inbred environment that’s NOT conducive to doing inspired and creative work. There are a few inspired photographers, but in terms of the masses, I would say that most work is uninspired.
What is Photography Composition?
First a little definition… the term “photography composition” refers to that aspect of photography for how objects and subjects are arranged (composed) within a photograph. Discussions about photographic composition revolve around topics like “is the subject matter centered or is it off-center”, “is the subject large or small”, “is it in focus or not in focus”. and etc. Composition is a formal element in the visual arts world that looks at the placement and arrangement of elements within a composition. The arrangement of objects can greatly influence the meaning and strength of the visual piece.
A well known photography composition rule is one called the “Rule of Thirds“. This rule is taught in most beginning photography classes. It’s basically a rule that was created to prevent beginners from always centering their subjects within a photograph. The reality is that a centered subject is actually quite static and uninteresting. To bring more interest to a photograph, beginning photographers are instructed to use the “Rule of Thirds” when composing their photographs. It’s a commonly used rule that is often times brought up during photography critique seesions.
There are many, many types of rules like this in photography, although I won’t go into detail about them here. I’ve seen literally hundreds of these rules listed on a single web page. Again, The variations of composition rules for photography are staggering.
A Photographic Case Study
There’s a classic example of photographers doing the exact same thing over and over again in the Twin Cities. In fact, I would say that at least a third of of all local photographers at the shows we’ve attended are showing practically the same photograph. In fact, this one image keeps showing up all over the Twin Cities. It’s is also currently featured on most local news broadcasts.
The image? It’s of the Stone Arch Bridge in Minneapolis, Minnesota. In fact, the City of Minneapolis currently lists it as one of the top five photo opportunities in the city.
The image of the Stone Arch Bridge (displayed here) shows up often at art festivals. There’s also a version that’s photographed to right of this viewpoint, but on the other side of the bridge with a more obstructed skyline.
So what makes an image of this bridge so appealing to fine art photographers? Well, certainly it’s a beautiful bridge that was built in 1883. It’s also considered one of the most famous landmarks in Minneapolis and very nicely lit at night.
My hunch is that photographer’s create this image over and over again because they know there’s demand for it. Unfortunately their motivations are sales, not creating inspired and imaginative work.
I have intentionally steered clear of shooting this same bridge. You just won’t find it in my portfolio of work primarily because I feel it’s been overdone and shown too many times. At some point I may decide to present it in a much different manner, but if I did, I’d want to bring something unique to this already iconic image.
Being Yourself As a Photographer
I’m certainly not suggesting that rules regarding photography composition are a bad thing, in fact I studied them as an undergraduate in Studio Art. Rules like these provide a foundation for growth as an artist. But, if you’re going to do work that is more personalized and unique, at some point you need to move on and start developing their own personalized style and “rules”.
How is this done? Here’s a listing of basic tips for developing your own style:
- Become familiar with the basic rules of photography, for example the “Rule of Thirds”. Don’t go overboard with studying those rules, just learn the basics and move on.
- Be sure your technical skills are decent enough to capture those images that you really want. Work on focusing, “depth of field” and exposure.
- Look at the work of other photographers. Take mental notes of the overall composition and subject matter. Pay close attention to how the image was “cropped” and from what angle it was photographed. Ask yourself if there’s a way to improve on the overall image and make it more interesting or meaningful.
- Create a notebook that contains personal notes or ideas about subjects that you’d like to focus your work on. If you see an image you really like in a newspaper, magazine or online, make a copy and paste it in your notebook. Try to identify what it is important about these images and make notes about them for future reference.
- Write down what’s important to you as an artist. Take lots of notes and keep refining your interests until your ready to start working on your next photography project.
In conclusion, it’s important to realize that there’s no right or wrong approach to developing a personalized style. The notes and ideas you create are uniquely your own and you are the judge of what’s right or wrong. Worry less about the marketability of an image and more about why it’s important to you.
If you want to do a series of photographs about a pet or child, do so! Don’t let anyone convince you that it won’t be interesting. Some of the most interesting and influential photographers have done portraits of dogs or family members. You are the ruler of the creative kingdom and the world is at your beck and call. Finally, learn the rules of photography composition, but don’t let them rule your life.
If you have additional thoughts or ideas, please comment below…